5 Bob Gibson (1959-1975), Right Hander
251-174 Record, 2.91 ERA, 3,117 Strikeouts You want to tell Gibson that he’s not one of the Top 5 pitchers of all time? I dare you. Even at his age you’ll probably get fastball aimed right at your head. Gibson was the first Black major league pitcher to throw a no-hitter.
4 Eddie Plank (1901-1914), Left Hander
326-194 Record, 2.35 ERA, 2,246 Strikeouts, 66 Shutouts Besides his outstanding numbers and being one of the best lefthanders in history, Plank helped lead the Philadelphia A’s to not one, but two World Series titles. He had an ERA under three in 15 out of his 17 seasons in the majors. There should be a statute of him in the city instead of that freaking Rocky.
3 Denton True “Cy” Young (1890-1911), Right Hander
511-316 Record, 2.63 ERA, 2,803 Strikeouts, 76 Shutouts Young was so good that Major League Baseball named an award after him for the best pitcher of the year. When you get an award named after you, that’s good enough to be on any Top 5 list. Young won more games than anyone in baseball history. And what kind of name is Denton True?
2 Christy Mathewson (1900-1916), Right Hander
373-188 Record, 2.13 ERA, 2,507 Strikeouts, 79 Shutouts Besides Johnson, there was no one better than Mathewson. He is the only pitcher to throw three shutouts in one World Series. Mathewson started playing in the minor leagues when he was 14 years old and won 20 games. Apparently child labor laws weren’t like they are today.
1 Walter Johnson (1907-1927), Right Hander
417-279 Record, 2.17 ERA, 1,061 Strikeouts, 110 Shutouts Johnson is the greatest pitcher of all time in any era, which makes one wonder ‘why wasn’t the pitcher of the year award named after him?’ Among his many great stats are the 11 sub-2.00 ERA seasons and the 12 20-plus win seasons and 110 shutouts. His baseball card is still worth enough to buy a small country.
Sandy Koufax (1955-1966), Left Hander
165-87 Record, 2.76 ERA, 2,396 Strikeouts
Koufax only played for 10 seasons, but had an incredible impact on the Dodgers and Major League Baseball. From 1961-1966 Koufax was nearly untouchable. Was forced to retire at age 30 because of arthritis in his left elbow. Koufax is at the top of the top 10 Jewish Athletes of all time.
Nolan Ryan (1966-1993), Right Hander
324-292 Record, 3.19 ERA, 5,714 Strikeouts, 7 No-Hitters
The Texas Rangers, where Ryan is both the president and owner, were one strike away from winning the World Series in 2011 and let it all get away. Imaging what would have been the outcome if Ryan had thrown that last pitch. Even at age 65.
Steve Carlton (1965-1988), Left Hander
329-244 Record, 3.22 ERA, 4,136 Strikeouts
Carlton was nicknamed “Lefty” because he threw left-handed. Wonder what they would have called him if he threw with both hands? He may be one of the most underrated greatest pitchers of all time mainly because he hated talking to the media. One thing hardly anyone knows about Carlton – he picked off 144 batters for the most of all time. Second is Jerry Koosman with 82.